An argument in favour of farm data as a public good

This is a submission to the 2021 John Ralph Essay Competition hosted by the Farm Institute's Farm Policy Journal.

An argument in favour of farm data as a public good

This is a submission to the 2021 John Ralph Essay Competition hosted by the Farm Institute's Farm Policy Journal.

I was awarded an honourable mention, and, given the deeply conservative context in which the Journal is embedded, I reckon that mention was being pretty brave on the judges' part!

Farm data is a concept that covers everything from this season's digital GPS logs for a million dollar combine to 40 years of rainfall readings in a tattered notebook next to the tea table.

It's the artefacts of property-level intelligence that Australian farmers produce every day, and much of it is private.

It's this privacy I take aim at, using the lens of the commons and the ideals of the UN Declaration of Universal Human Rights:

Farm data should be a public good. All land management information should be public by default. The proposition is advanced through two assertions:
1 - The production of food ought to be a public service, not a speculative competition. Data associated with the farmer’s practice is a critical source of intelligence that should be available to assist with an optimised farming practice in aggregate.
2 - Farming practice ought to be coordinated as an act of reciprocity with all land and people rather than through an imagined isolation from considerations such as ecosystem health and community well-being. The management of land can only proceed with high levels of cooperative land care practice

Clearly, this takes a completely contrary approach to the dominant idea that farming is a private, for-profit activity, and that this arrangement somehow delivers:

  • optimised land use
  • best-case outcomes for ecosystem utilisation, care, and flourishing
  • highest-quality, nutrient-dense food appropriate for the people consuming it

Anyway, enjoy the essay!