Evolving nature-based solutions for Australia’s Indigenous estate in 2024 – opportunities and challenges

Evolving nature-based solutions for Australia’s Indigenous estate in 2024 – opportunities and challenges
Private profits and public costs: are markets really the answer?

Markets provide the language that policy makers rely on when looking for ways to fund large, public-good expenditure. In the prevailing neo-liberal climate, it is virtually impossible to make a case for direct allocation of state funds to meet the broad needs of society. Instead, governments wrap themselves in knots trying to make it look like commercial-scale "investment" will flow as soon as a sufficiently well-hyped market has been established.

Despite the overwhelming evidence against the effectiveness of such a strategy, the number and diversity of "nature based solutions" or (NbS) has continued to grow.

I was invited to be a minor contributor to this essay which was led by the always impressive Dr Jeremy Russell-Smith and Prof Kamaljit Sangha. Jarrad Holmes anchored a number of the key arguments with in-depth analysis, and Ben Lewis provided invaluable insights from his deep experience as both a practitioner and innovator in this sector.

To date, Indigenous NbS interests have focused especially on savanna fire management across northern Australia. Most available schemes focus on remediation of degraded lands and seas, ignoring cost-effective investment opportunities to maintain habitats and ecosystems in less-degraded condition. Government supported Common Asset Trusts can provide effective models for governance of stewardship schemes relevant to on-going care for relatively intact ecosystems. We summarise key methodological, institutional, and policy opportunities and challenges for constructive Indigenous engagement with developing NbS markets. Our purpose in the essay is to provide an Indigenous land and sea management context to inform development of rapidly evolving NbS markets in Australia.